By now you probably know all about Denver the guilty dog, who is responsible for one of the most all-time cute dog videos in Internet history. Denver became an international celebrity, and after seeing that guilty smile, we’ve all been waiting for Denver, the sequel.

Well, he’s back, and just in time to leave us a Christmas gift! As soon as we saw him on the couch, we started grinning just like he does when he’s caught red-handed. Or in this case, red-lipped!

What did he do this time? Watch and find out. And for the record, we’re not completely buying Macie’s innocent act. That’s the second time she pretends like she has no clue what’s going on, while her friend is busy being, well, Denver the guilty dog.